Review topics: ["size","fit","length","support","color","fabric","material","issues","design","quality","look","addition","lining","feel","shape","pants","comfort","style","stretch","service","pattern","customer service","width","shoes","texture","difference","coverage","point","fun","padding"].
Reviews
Cute but different quality?
"These flats are so cute. I have two other older pairs of the point and I love them, however, I have worn these a few times and have some blisters on my heels from a break in period. I have never had a break in period with any of my Rothy’s before and definitely never gotten blisters before. The shoes are still cute, but not sure if the quality has dropped from previous versions."
— Laura H. (4/5)
Cute / Not comfortable / A bit tight
"Super cute flats and I love the style! I normally wear a size 6. 5 in flats, but these ran a bit narrow and small, so I’d recommend sizing up half a size. The heel also felt pretty stiff and gave me blisters after wearing them. I noticed others mentioned the same issue, and I think a slightly lower heel counter would make them much more comfortable."
— Nojan S. (4/5)
Loving them even more, second time around
"I got my first pair of Rothy's as a gift from my brother. At first sight, I resisted. He insisted. I tried them on and fell in love. After a few years, they started to feel a tad tight and a bit worn out. I bought the exact same pair, this time 0. 5 size bigger. Loving them all over again. What I have come to love just as much is the sales and after sales service. The experience at the store in Austin was delightful both times - attentive, friendly, patient salesperson who followed up via a personal email after purchase - when she simply didnt need to. Makes for a great experience and a loyal customer."
— Megha J. (5/5)
Really chic shoe
"These are the only point shoes I've found that are as comfortable as a slipper. The fabric moves with your foot to accommodate those outer toes that get smushed in most other shoes. And they just look so good! I do go up a 1/2 size at least for the points - and they aren't too big at all. They dont slip off my feet or rub in any way."
— Jennifer S. (5/5)
Ripped Off
"Thought it was terrible that your company put a sale on a shoe and then 3 days later discounted the shoes another 20%. I will never buy from Rothy’s again when they first announce a sale. If I don’t get them I’ll be fine with that. You just made your customers feel like “suckers” for buying them when you first announced a sale! Not smart marketing for the customers who consistently buy your shoes."
— Nancy D. (3/5)
Thought they would be more navy
"I have these shoes in black and taupe and really wanted dark navy, but wear them anyway and they go fine with navy suit that I wear them with. So comfortable and classic and I can walk fast with no fear of tripping due to slip proof sole."
— Shavon M. (4/5)
Comfy and stylish
"Great shoe. Regret not buying sooner. The material is much softer and knit- like than I expected. The “recycled water bottles” always made me cautious but they aren’t hard plastic at all. Perfect with leggings, jeans, dress pants and shorts."
— Emily L. (5/5)
L O V E Rothy's
"Rothy's has nailed comfortable shoes that actually look nice. They are in fact so comfortable, that I have sold about 30 other pairs of other flats that I owned. I also bought 5 other pairs of Rothy's to coordinate with more of my clothing. THAT is how much I love these shoes."
— Katherine R. (5/5)
Comfortabl!
"I love the fact that I can place my orthotics under the liner in the shoe: it makes the shoe both comfortable & supportive! Also love the wide sizing: hope to see more wide color options!"
— Claudia E. (5/5)
Hooray for Wide!
"I’ve worn Rothy Points for years but they are so much more comfortable now that there is a wide option! They are a bit looser with the wide version, and have a short break-in period, so I had a little trouble with the high backs causing irritation. However, an easy fix was to use Dr. Scholl’s Heel Liner Cusions."
— Mandy F. (4/5)