Review topics: ["size","fit","strap","support","weight","color","fabric","issues","quality","look","feel","shoes","comfort","style","stretch","mary janes","padding","comfy","band","feet","rothy","cruise","pair","toe","insole","cushion","flats","break","footbed","walk"].
Reviews
Love these! Just wish it didn’t have a blue stripe on the heel
"The only thing keeping me from getting these five stars is the weird royal blue stripe on the back of the heel. I interferes with styling and outfits and it’s just such a weird thing to do to your shoe. I wish it wasn’t there and I’m thinking of drawing on it with black sharpie to cover it up."
— Talli T. (4/5)
My new favorite shoe
"I bought the children’s version of these for my niece and thought they were precious. When on a trip to DC, I wanted to go into the Rothys store to try on some loafers and Mary Jane’s since there’s not a store in Charleston, SC. I had no plans for the cruisers for myself but decided to try them on and holy cow! Love them! I am flat footed and have had two surgeries on my right foot. I typically need a 10 wide in shoes. These are wonderful, spacious, comfy and don’t hurt my feet at all!"
— Amanda C. (5/5)
Cute, comfortable
"Great shoes for urban summer walking. As is often the case with Rothy’s, sizing is unpredictable. I typically wear size 8. These were practically falling off my feet. Exchanged for 7. 5 which are still big but 7 was too snug. Really wish Rothy’s sizing was consistent"
— jeanne b. (5/5)
Cute, good for short walks
"I like these a lot, but they are not as cushy as I expected. I added a heel cushion, which helped during long walks around Paris. The red adds a fun pop of color, and I've received compliments. Note that they are not a great hot weather shoe, as they don't breathe as much as one might expect. I wore thin peds , which helped keep them fresh. I would love it if Rothys would create more breathable footbed!"
— Alexandra J. (3/5)
Cute and comfy!
"These shoes are so comfortable! I bought my usual size and they fit great! No sore feet, blisters, and the colors are so cute!"
— Carolyn N. (5/5)
The shoe I keep reaching for
"The red cruiser Mary Jane is the most adorable comfortable shoe. I can’t stop reaching for them this summer. If you’re hesitating definitely buy it- comfortable from the second I put them on, and I walk a lot. Perfect shade of red, true to size."
— Maria U. (5/5)
Love the Mary Jane
"I bought the black ones, because I already have it in other colors. I love the style, size and the colors."
— Maria R. (5/5)
Toe Box and Bunions
"As someone who has a bunion on both feet, I was excited for these Mary Jane’s bc of the soft sides. First, they are very comfortable and lasted a day at an amusement park with ease, HOWEVER…the opening above the toes on the front actually cuts across in a way that hits the bunions instead of them being cradled inside the soft material. I understand shows aren’t one size fits all issues, but narrow toe boxes and weird cuts in the fit/style, make them very uncomfortable despite how everything else feels. I might never wear them again and as a teacher I was really looking forward to wearing them in my classroom and interacting with my students. But the way they hurt would ruin my whole day. :("
— Catherine K. (2/5)
Great daily summer shoe!
"Vibrant color. Easy on/off. Goes with everything. Packs easily. Comfortable to wear all day long. Fits like a slipper. Definitely recommend."
— Elisabeth G. (5/5)
So cute and comfy!
"I absolutely love these Mary Jane cruisers. The poppy color is adorable, and the shoes are very comfortable! The first time I wore them, I walked around town for 6 hours. I experienced zero discomfort, rubbing, or soreness. I wear an 11. 5 in drivers but the 11 was perfect for me in the cruisers."
— Laura D. (5/5)